YachtsmanRetirementInvesting.com

Caution, Patience and Market Extremes
Home
CURRENT UPDATE
Carl Mathison is Yachtsman
Charitable Donations
National Kidney Foundation
Investing for Retirement
Who is the Market?
Market and Trading Desks Updates
The Yachtsman Newsletter
Yachtsman Investment Articles
Fundamental Indicators
Basic Technical Analysis
Sector Indicators and Diversification Models
Fixed Income Investing
Yachtsman Stock Spotlight
Social Security
Questions for Yachtsman
Favorite Web Sites
Investor Library
Contact Yachtsman
Reader Comments
The Yachtsman Anchor for Retirement Investing
Disclaimers and Disclosures

Caution, Patience and Dealing with Extremes

Caution, Patience and Extremes ... September 23. 2007
 
Carl Mathison is Yachtsman
 

No market goes up in a straight line. Not even a Fed fed 50 basis point rate cut market. Marty Zweig said thirty years ago, "Don't fight the Fed" and he was right. But I never heard Marty say "...and therefore the market will never correct." On the contrary, disciplines become more important than ever when markets run hard in either direction. 

I recently wrote that the FOMC meeting on September 18 would cause a sea change for the stock market. I believe that is exactly what has occurred. But not all of those sea changes are bullish. The potential for much higher inflation is undeniable. The weakening dollar and higher oil prices are at historic levels. The disclosures of deeper sub prime exposure by banks, brokerages and hedge funds are virtually a given and that is to name just a few of the problems facing the U.S. economy and the stock market.

Gold is not hitting a new multi-year high because of jewelry demand. Bonds have not reacted so aggressively because of a strengthening domestic economy. Those 50 point cuts on the Fed funds and Discount rate scared the hell out of the bond market. Were it not for exports, we would be in a recession right now. The housing market has made that abundantly clear. As I mentioned last week, eight out of the last ten recessions were preceded by a housing boom and a subsequent housing devaluation.  

So, Yacht has turned bearish. No, I have not turned bearish and I have not turned bullish. I have turned neither because I am, as always, neither bullish nor bearish. I simply take what the market gives me. I don't form a market sentiment, I utilize market sentiment. I am patient. I strive to be consistent. I work hard to be persistent and I always try to be loyal to my objectives and perspectives.

Just as in football or golf or any other sport you wish to name, you utilize to your advantage what your opponent or the conditions of the game are giving you. If the defense is set to stop the pass, you run the ball. If there is water behind the green, you take one less club and play up short. It's the same in any business. Patience, consistency, persistency and loyalty are the keys to success. Ignore any one these attributes of success and you will lose. That I can guarantee. Maybe not this week or this year but you will ultimately lose the game, whatever that game may be.

Patience is the antidote to emotion. Emotions in the market are fear and greed. Emotion is the basis for bad decision making and bad decision making is the key to losses in the stock market or any other business. Patience is discipline.

Consistency is the ability to repeatedly apply what you have learned through experience, developed through trial and error and tested in actual application on a constant basis. I think of my investing disciplines as the ultimate test of consistency and therefore, patience. When I fail to follow my disciplines consistently, I invariably lose money.

Persistency is dogma. It's never giving up. It's staying in the game even when the game isn't fun that day or every position is moving the wrong way. Persistency allows you to win even when self-doubt tries to creep in. It's the discipline to force yourself to remain patient, to consistently follow your disciplines and remain loyal to your values, objectives and long-term perspectives in the market and in life. It's a system of principles that must be established and followed everyday and without exception. Persistency separates success from failure.

Loyalty is the ability to not just think about you. Loyalty is the ability to set aside your personal desire for immediate success and the instant gratification of profit in the stock market or any other aspect of life. Loyalty is a perspective that is mandatory for success. It's the "I'm just looking out for me" attitude that I have seen cause so many talented athletes, traders, businesspeople and personal relationships to fail. Loyalty is the ability to look out longer-term at the bigger picture and put patience, consistency and persistence to work. Whether it's establishing your personal priorities, your investment objectives, implementing your business plan, or following your stock market disciplines, loyalty is a perspective that influences your trading as well as every aspect of your life.    

So no, I have not turned bullish or bearish. I remain consistently agnostic. A stock market agnostic that will take what the market will give me while I remain patient, consistently following my disciplines and persistently trying my best to be loyal to my perspectives, objectives and the longer-term big picture which has proven to me to be one of the most important aspects of successful living and investing.

Successful investing also requires constant reevaluation of the over all market picture. At every moment the market's overall big picture is telling the real story. Markets do not move in a vacuum. It's not just about the next stock pick. It's an understanding of the numerous market variables that interact and correlate with one another to create the market's overall picture and future direction.

Any investor who has placed their hard earned money at risk in the markets should be able to take every bearish argument I listed above and answer them with the bullish response. That's what makes a long-term successful investor because that's what makes the market move. The constant push and pull between the bearish and the bullish arguments is what moves the markets and establishes the momentum and prices of stocks.

Sure, the weak dollar can be bullish for stocks as take-over bids from foreign firms and corporations increase and our multinational companies benefit across the board. High oil prices are the market leader when sectors like agriculture, machinery, mining and infrastructure are in demand. Higher "potential" inflation is no reason to hold back economic growth with high interest rates. All sound responses to the bearish arguments.

So we are once again at the point where it would appear the bullish arguments balance the bearish arguments and vice versa. As we constantly evaluate the market we have to search for variables within the market that provide insight as to where we are in the market's ongoing cycles and where we may be going as the market performs it's task as a discounting mechanism for a stream of future earnings. They may be fundamental aspects of the market, quantitative models, technical aspects that allow numerical or visual analysis of market price, volume or any number of other different variables used to evaluate the markets and their components.

At this point, after the run we have had this past week, it would be difficult to argue that the market is not extremely overbought. That by no means implies the market is overvalued or cannot move yet higher. These indicators are not always correlated and can be at extremes in totally variant directions for prolonged periods. An overbought market may still be undervalued; just as an oversold market can simultaneously be overvalued by any accepted metric.  

However, at any given moment in the market there exist extremes. It is when variables within the market reach extremes that insight into the markets can be evaluated and utilized by the persistent investor willing to have the consistency and patience to loyally follow their disciplines and achieve their investment objectives.

An excellent example within the current market environment occurred late last week when the percentage of stocks that had moved above their 40 day moving average reached an overbought extreme. Not only did this percentage of stocks move to overbought extremes, they moved from a previously oversold reading to overbought within a few days.

The Worden T2108 chart below measures the percentage of stocks above their 40 day moving average.

 

Source: TC2000

Notice how the move off the lower level represents a parabolic rise in the indicator and creates an extreme move from oversold to overbought following the FOMC Fed Funds rate cut. I believe this extreme reaction sets the stage for some profit taking by investors disciplined to book at least partial gains at this point. It also serves as an actionable alert to many market participants' of the extremely emotional and impatient response by the market to the FOMC's actions. Technical and "black box" selling will be triggered by this indicator.

Another example of a variable that may provide us with current market insight is the options market's extreme reversal in put buying. I believe this action provides another emotional response to the Fed's actions. The fear of missing a sustained upside market move has caused fund managers of all types to chase leveraged performance through increased call buying and lowered options volatility. As a contra-indicator, this action may indicate a short-term topping action as a lessening of fear and volatility implies complacency and the VIX, or Chicago Board Options Exchange's Market Volatility Index, falls from 25 to 19.

Additionally, and as an indicator of overall market psychology, the market action this week showed a total disregard for the bearish economic indications that accompany a 50 basis point reduction in the Fed Funds rate. The Fed does not cut 50 basis points to assist a strong and well performing economy free from financial crisis and concerns. The market is aware of these concerns and the possibility that economic conditions and on going sub prime defaults may actually be worse than originally or currently anticipated. But we are in an extreme market environment where negatives are being ignored and that is always the cause for caution, patience and discipline.                 

At this moment in the market, the bullish scenarios that accompany the Fed's actions are outweighing any bearish consequences. All news is being interpreted as bullish news to the extent and extreme it can be for the equity markets. This market's response is creating the discernable extremes and possible insights that we must monitor as we constantly reevaluate the market's cycle, current performance and future direction.

I believe the market's extreme emotional response and the indicators that reflect the reaction to the FOMC's action require increased patience and consistent market discipline. Loyal to my investment perspectives and objectives, I will not fight the Fed but I will remain a market agnostic in anticipation of a market correction in response to these extremes. Markets and stocks do not go up in a straight line. I believe the current overall market picture will provide buying opportunities from more favorable levels and at better entry points for my longer-term portfolios. In the meantime, I'll simply take what the market gives me, make small moves and book staged profits. I urge you to do the same.

As always I welcome your comments or questions.

yacht